Hello everyone!
Today I’m going to be fully dissecting a topic that I’ve mentioned in passing on this blog many times: my ultimate decision on whether or not I will be continuing to be a high school cheerleader after this season. This year’s season is not officially over until about halfway through February, but basketball is not nearly as popular of a sport at my school as football, so it already feels like it’s dwindled down. Regardless, now that I’m almost done with my second season as a high school cheerleader, I feel more confident in my feelings about it and the next step for me. As the title of this post suggests, I’ve (VERY carefully) decided that I do not plan on trying out for next year’s cheer season this spring.
Whenever I bring this up to people in conversation, they’re always shocked. I’m not sure if it’s like this at other schools, but at my school, the sports team/major activity (choir, band, Academic Decathlon, journalism/yearbook) you’re involved with is a huge part of your “school persona” (more on why I use this term later). My friends say, “Why don’t you want to do it anymore? Don’t you like it? Don’t you at least want it to show consistency on your college application?”. And they have a point- in the beginning of my freshman year, when I first joined the cheer team, I was obsessed with being on cheer. I wouldn’t shut up about it; it wasn’t because I thought I was cooler than everyone else since I was a cheerleader, it was because I had never been on a sports team or anything similar before cheer.
In fact, one of the main reasons I kept going back and forth about continuing with cheer was how it would reflect on my college applications come senior year. If I continued, I would be on varsity next year (if I made it; all juniors are on varsity), and I could say I’d been in a varsity sport in high school; I could say I’d been committed to a sport for four years in high school as well. Sports are a huge time commitment, and that’s definitely a big component of a lot of high schoolers’ lives and extracurricular commitments. I also thought being a cheerleader specifically might be a “hook” in some way for more prestigious schools, since cheerleaders are often stereotyped as dumb, and schools want diversity/people from all sports and activities that break stereotypes.
Furthermore, I worried about my own self-esteem regarding the decision- would I feel like a quitter? Even though it’s totally my right to decide not to try out again after finishing up this season, I somehow felt like that was a failure in a way. I’m kind of a perfectionist and I’m clearly quite hard on myself, so to stop doing cheer would be to admit that it wasn’t for me and that I couldn’t master it. I’ve had to come to terms with the fact that I don’t want to spend my time trying to “master” cheerleading, and that’s perfectly okay- I can use my time on other things I love, like writing. I think part of the reason I felt so bad about stopping is that I’ve never really stuck to a sport or a major organized activity for more than a year, but I’ve been doing cheer for three years if you count eighth grade. It was one of those situations where you feel like you’ve come so far and don’t want to stop now, but I had to get myself out of that mentality; continuing cheer would hurt me more than help me in the long run.
As far as the reasons I wanted to quit, there were many. First of all, I wasn’t good at cheer, and although that’s not a reason to quit on its own, it made it a lot harder to enjoy the season. At our school, after sideline cheer season is over, there’s a competitive season; even though sidelines season is kind of a joke, competitive season is super intense. I knew I didn’t want to be on the competition team last year, so I didn’t try out. A lot of the girls on my team did, so coming into this year’s season they had a bunch of new skills and were so much stronger- I wasn’t. Second, the coaches didn’t like me. Favoritism is very prevalent in our program, and they pretty much only like the girls who were on the competition team (yes, a lot of them are more skilled, but not everyone- and that’s not the point). Since I wasn’t very good, that exacerbated their frustration with me.
Those last two reasons were fairly minor in my decision-making process, but combined with the bigger reasons I’ll discuss now, there were too many reasons for me to quit, and almost none to stay. One of the main things I was struggling with was that I didn’t feel included on the team, and I wasn’t a fan of the dynamic (partially because of the favoritism). Our team is mainly divided into two parts: a big friend group of girls that has all done cheer together since they were little, and everyone else who joined cheer for other reasons. My best friend was on the team with me, but she had been on the competition team and is super talented, and therefore was more well-liked by everyone- I wasn’t. I always felt like an outsider but I didn’t even want to try to fit in with the other girls because I knew I wouldn’t, and I would just be making a fool out of myself.
Feeling excluded only contributed to my dread over going to practices and games. Cheer, just like any other sport, is a significant time commitment. During football season, between two-hour practices everyday and six-hour game days including travel, I would spend anywhere from 12-15 hours doing cheer per week (more if there were special events like school rallies or performances outside of school). I didn’t have as much time for other activities I had wanted to join or spend more time on (like writing!) and I wasn’t even getting anything out of the experience since I was finding myself hating going to cheer more and more. It felt like a huge waste of my time, and it was hard to know that cheer was the reason I didn’t have time to pursue things I actually enjoy, or at least be more productive/have more time to study/etc. I know these are normal things that come with being in a sport, but that’s the thing- most people in sports either stay in it because they like it or because they’re good at it, ideally both. At this point, I was in neither of those situations.
For these reasons and probably more I’ve forgotten by now, I made up my mind that this cheer season will be my last. Am I scared I made the wrong decision? Of course. Am I worried I’ll end up missing it somehow? Obviously. Am I going to change my mind? I can’t say for sure, but I really don’t think so. The thing that’s helped me is quite a few of my friends have gone through similar experiences with their respective sports this year, and a few of them have even quit already/mid-season. I felt a lot less lonely because of that, and a lot more confident in my decision; I need to do what’s best for me and what will lead me to happiness. And you know what? Even though this season’s not over yet, I feel better already.
One thing I wanted to address that’s not directly related to ending my high school cheer career: my tumbling classes/cheer experiences outside of school. For about two years, I’ve been taking tumbling classes with coaches from the gym that I cheered at in eighth grade. This year, that was structured into one private lesson per week/sometimes every other week with one coach, and a group lesson every week with a different coach. Even though I knew I wouldn’t be continuing cheer, I told myself I wanted to just keep going to tumbling for a little bit and see if it was something I still enjoyed outside of cheer. The last few lessons I went to, I felt unmotivated and I just wanted to get them over with. It was kind of an abrupt decision, but I decided to stop attending tumbling classes as well. It feels really weird not driving to the familiar cheer gym every week, but I honestly don’t really miss it yet. I think it was just time for me to move on.
Since basketball season is going on, I’m getting a little bit of exercise through cheer every week. However, once cheer is over, I will have no structured physical activity in my life. I think it’s super important that I find a replacement form of exercise since it’s important for me to be outside and get my vitamin D, and I still want to stay in shape. This means you can expect some upcoming health/fitness related content!
-Brooke